David Kilgour faced skepticism from various quarters when he first co-authored one of several reports that said prisoners of conscience were being killed on demand for their organs in China.
Twelve years from the release of his first report in 2006, the former Canadian Secretary of State (Asia-Pacific) and other independent researchers have gone on to solidify their findings and affect broad change. A U.S. House of Representatives resolution condemned the Chinese state’s harvesting of organs from prisoners of conscience in 2016 and a similar resolution passed by the European Parliament in 2013 are but two examples.
Recently, Kilgour and others spoke at a second roundtable meeting at Westminster on how the British government can help prevent what is occurring.
As part of his talk, Kilgour discussed how international transplant professionals have dealt with the issue and how their responses differ.
— StopOrganHarvesting (@StopOrganTheft) April 21, 2018
He told the meeting — hosted by Jim Shannon MP and Fiona Bruce MP — that the stance of the global transplantation profession can currently be categorized into three groups.
The first group, he said, are those professionals who are aware of what is going on.
“The aware [those] who have read the research and realize that what is going on in China with transplantations is mass killing of innocents and cover up,” said Kilgour. “They react accordingly, distancing themselves from the Chinese transplant profession and encouraging others to do likewise.”
NEWSLETTER, Spring 2018, with interview, updates and international news on transplant #medical ethics and #forced organ harvesting. @smithmarion @SophieHRW https://t.co/gKcwkWa95y pic.twitter.com/ZnaYufW9pn
— DAFOH (@DAFOH_org) March 23, 2018
The second group are those who are naïve.
“The naïve do not consider the research and argue that doing so falls outside their area of responsibility,” he said. “They hear research conclusions on the one hand and Party-state propaganda on the other and draw no conclusions.”
Then there are those — the foolish — who have accepted the Party line.
“The foolish buy Chinese Party-state propaganda. They parrot its line that the research demonstrating mass killing of innocents is based on rumor,” Kilgour said. “They echo the Party line that the research is unverifiable, though it is both verifiable and verified. They repeat its claim that abuses are in the past, when they are not.”
These, he said, are also professionals who should know better, and he was especially critical of the global transplant leadership.
“The four organizations (World Health Organization, the Vatican’s Pontifical Academy of Sciences, The Transplantation Society, and the Declaration of Istanbul Custodian Group) are pleased that the Party says what they want to hear,” he said.
This all flies in the face of hard evidence and weak denials from Chinese officials.
Fact: organ donation is taboo in China-organs are rare. Yet “approximately 1.5 million transplants have taken place at 712 liver and kidney transplant centres across China since 2000, with over 300,000 of those taking place at unregulated centres.” https://t.co/AQNaD7D43X… pic.twitter.com/h1nOx1A4qG
— DAFOH (@DAFOH_org) March 17, 2018
“Beijing has no credible answers to the work of independent researchers who have demonstrated the mass killings of innocents. Given the scale of the transplantation industry in China, it is impossible to deny this research in any credible manner,” Kilgour said.
“Party propaganda, denying official data, pretending what is there is not there can persuade only the gullible or the willfully blind,” he said. “One can only hope that a willingness to confront the truth about China will prevail generally in the transplantation profession before many more innocents are killed for their organs.”
Also speaking at the meeting was U.S. investigative reporter Ethan Gutmann, who coauthored a report in 2016 with Kilgour and another Canadian — human rights lawyer David Matas. Their 817-page report titled Bloody Harvest/The Slaughter: An Update, found that organ harvesting in China is much worse than previously thought. Instead of 10,000 organ transplants being done per year as quoted by Chinese officials, the new report says that around 60,000 to 100,000 transplants are performed each year in China.
The main target for organ harvesting, the report said, are Chinese who adhere to the meditation practice of Falun Gong, people who are being persecuted by the communist authorities for their peaceful beliefs. Other prisoners of conscience also targeted and killed for their organs — but in relatively smaller numbers — are Tibetans, Uyghurs, and house Christians.
Any discussion of #forced organ harvesting is incomplete without a basic understanding of Falun Gong and insight about how Chinese communist party propaganda has created a bias against the very victims of crimes against humanity in China. https://t.co/oDh33VA0mv pic.twitter.com/S806xpNwX3
— DAFOH (@DAFOH_org) April 8, 2018